This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
This study set out to explore Iranian English as a foreign language (EFL) teachers’ perceptions on the implementation of online EFL instruction. A mixed-methods design, including semi-structured interviews and questionnaires, was employed for the specific purposes of this study. A total of 242 EFL teachers participated in the questionnaire phase of the study. In addition, 46 EFL teachers participated in the interview phase of the study. The teachers worked at a number of universities, schools and language-teaching institutions in Iran. Results suggest that although the Iranian EFL teachers adopted moderately positive attitudes towards the implementation of online instruction, the majority of them preferred blended instruction to online instruction. At the same time, the study revealed that the implementation of online EFL instruction in Iran is challenging due to a number of perceived impediments and obstacles. The most considerable perceived challenges to the implementation of online EFL instruction comprise lack of online facilities and resources, lack of interaction in online instruction, cultural resistances to online instruction and teachers’ limited knowledge of online instruction. The findings of this study provided crucial insights into teachers’ perspectives on a number of measures that can be adopted to facilitate the integration of online instruction in the EFL context of Iran. The findings would provide valuable insights for educational authorities and course designers to integrate online instruction into the EFL curriculum.
In recent years, educational decision makers and course designers from a wide range of educational institutions and universities have expressed growing interest in the implementation of online instruction (Beatty and Ulasewicz
Some experts of educational technology and online instruction contend that the implementation of online instruction might create limitations and challenges. Most importantly, lack of interaction between the instructors and students might be one considerable challenge of online instruction (Song
Despite these challenges and obstacles, online instruction has continued to be a robust and efficient approach to learning and teaching from the perspectives of many teachers and students (Li and Irby
Even though there is an abundance of research directed towards students’ perceptions on the implementation of online instruction in a wide range of educational contexts (e.g., Allen
Interestingly, results of several studies related to teachers’ perspectives on online instruction in educational contexts are indicative of teachers’ positive attitudes towards the implementation of online instruction. Specifically, some studies have been undertaken to assess teachers’ and students’ perspectives on online instruction using social constructivist approaches (e.g., Can
Even though, in language-teaching contexts, a plethora of studies have examined students’ attitudes towards online EFL instruction (Aydin
Concerning online instruction in Iran, Gharehbakloo ( What are the attitudes of Iranian EFL teachers towards the implementation of online instruction? What are the perceptions of EFL teachers on the possible challenges to the implementation of online instruction? What are the perceptions of EFL teachers on strategies that should be adopted to integrate online instruction in the Iranian EFL curriculum?
A mixed-methods design was adopted for the purposes of this study. More specifically, attempts were made to conduct a methodological triangulation through the use of a mixed-methods design. First, the use of such a design provided both confirmatory and supplementary data, which enriched the findings and their interpretations. Second, since methodological triangulation is an effective approach to obtaining valid and comprehensive interpretation of the research data (Best and Kahn
Initially, a Likert scale questionnaire was designed to investigate the attitudes of EFL teachers towards implementing online language teaching in Iran. The questionnaire was constructed and developed based on reviewing previous research on theories, practices and findings related to online instruction in EFL and educational contexts (e.g., Bijeikienė, Rašinskienė, and Zutkienė 2011; Corda and Stel
In addition, Cronbach's Alpha coefficients were calculated and the results showed high levels of reliability for the three sections of the survey (
Following the demographics items, a total of 31 items were included in the questionnaire. The first section of the questionnaire included items related to teachers’ attitudes towards implementing online EFL instruction. The items of the second section were constructed to identify the challenges and limitations of online EFL instruction from the perspective of EFL teachers. Finally, teachers’ perceptions of strategies to be adopted to implement online language teaching were explored through the inclusion of the last section of the questionnaire. Paper-based questionnaires were distributed and the teachers were invited to participate in the questionnaire phase of the study voluntarily.
As for the ethical considerations of the study, an informed consent letter was submitted to the teachers before their participation in the survey study. The consent letter was developed based on the guidelines of designing consent letters mentioned in Mackey and Gass (
Interviews were also used to enrich the results obtained from the survey study. A total of 46 EFL teachers accepted to take part in interviews. The responses of the participants were recorded during each interview session. The interviews were conducted throughout 6 weeks. The same panel of six professors validated the content of the questions of the interviews. Also, the same literature was used to construct the questions of the interviews. The interview questions were as follows: What are the possible benefits of online EFL instruction? What are the obstacles to the implementation of online EFL instruction in Iran? What types of strategies should be adopted to facilitate the inclusion of online EFL instruction in EFL curricula of Iran? Do you believe in the usefulness of blended EFL instruction or online EFL instruction for Iranian EFL students? Why? Do you think that you have adequate skills to teach in an online EFL instruction? Why do you think so?
The data of the questionnaire were analysed through performing a descriptive analysis. The mean and standard deviation were presented for the data related to each item of the questionnaire. SPSS version 16 was employed for the data analysis. To ensure the reliability of the data analysis, two different coders (including the author) read the data obtained by the interviews and then transcribed them. The emerging themes, which were verified by the two coders, were analysed and reported. Excerpts from teachers’ statements were included in the study.
The sample comprised 242 EFL teachers from eight different language-teaching institutions (
Participants’ demographic information.
| Gender | Male=98 | Female=144 |
|---|---|---|
|
|
||
| Average age | 34.4 | |
| Average years of teaching EFL | 8.7 | |
| Average years of using computers | 9.7 | |
| Average years of using the Internet | 7.6 | |
| University degrees | BA/BS: 172 | |
| MA/MS: 66 | ||
| PHD: 4 | ||
The survey As
Teachers’ attitudes towards online instruction
| Number of participants=242 | Mean | SD |
|---|---|---|
|
|
||
| Updated materials can be used in online EFL courses | 4.45 | 0.9 |
| Students will be more autonomous in online EFL courses | 4.24 | 0.79 |
| Online EFL courses enhance students’ motivation | 4.23 | 0.83 |
| Online EFL courses are time-efficient | 4.1 | 0.9 |
| Authentic materials are used in online EFL courses | 4.04 | 0.99 |
| Learners can communicate internationally in online EFL courses | 3.98 | 1.06 |
| Online EFL courses are based on learner-centred approaches to teaching | 3.94 | 0.91 |
| Online EFL courses are easily accessible to students | 3.9 | 1.22 |
| Multimedia can be used in online EFL courses | 3.86 | 1.19 |
| Various types of materials can be used in online EFL courses | 3.83 | 1.3 |
| Online EFL courses are cost-effective | 3.72 | 1.22 |
| Online EFL courses will promote students’ and teachers’ computer competence | 3.3 | 1.2 |
| Online EFL courses are in line with experiential approaches to leaning | 3.26 | 1.29 |
| Online EFL courses provide equal opportunities for learners to learn English | 3.13 | 1.11 |
| Online EFL courses promote collaboration among students | 3.06 | 1.41 |
| Expansive feedback can be provided for students in online EFL courses | 2.97 | 1.24 |
| Online EFL courses are easy to be implemented | 2.37 | 1.4 |
| Online EFL courses are more interactive than traditional courses | 2.36 | 1.25 |
Likert scales: 1, strongly disagree; 2, disagree; 3, undecided; 4, agree; 5, strongly agree.
The interview The responses to the first question of the interview regarding the merits of online EFL instruction showed the positive attitudes of the majority of EFL teachers. The teachers pointed out some benefits of online EFL instruction, including authenticity and variety of materials, promotion in students’ motivation to learn, accessibility for all students, and time and energy efficiency. Excerpts of the participants’ quotations confirm these positive attitudes: One problem for many students is spending a long time on learning. Students who lack time to attend EFL courses can benefit from online EFL courses a lot. These courses will be accessible to all students. (Teacher 17) Well … the problem is that the current EFL courses which are based on traditional approaches to teaching EFL are not very motivating for EFL students. Using technology especially online EFL teaching might help language teachers to switch to more modern approaches to teaching and improve students’ motivation and interest in learning a language. (Teacher 30)
The survey Based on the findings illustrated in
Obstacles to the implementation of online instruction.
|
|
Mean | SD |
|---|---|---|
|
|
||
| There is a lack of online facilities in EFL courses | 4.32 | 0.78 |
| Students lack the necessary Internet-based skills to participate in online ELT courses | 4.09 | 0.98 |
| There are cultural resistances to the implementation of online EFL teaching | 3.87 | 0.94 |
| There is a lack of interaction in online EFL courses | 3.82 | 1.05 |
| Students do not have positive attitudes towards online EFL courses | 3.68 | 1 |
| Online EFL courses are just appropriate for autonomous students | 3.67 | 1.17 |
| There is not much teacher supervision over students in online EFL courses | 3.1 | 1.3 |
| Online EFL courses are not responsive to students’ needs | 2.88 | 1.31 |
| Online EFL teaching is costly to be implemented in TEFL contexts | 2.82 | 1.21 |
| Online EFL courses place a lot of demands on EFL teachers | 2.58 | 1.13 |
| Online EFL courses are not motivating for students | 2.42 | 1.1 |
Likert scales: 1, strongly disagree; 2, disagree; 3, undecided; 4, agree; 5, strongly agree.
The interview The EFL teachers were asked about the limitations which might impede the inclusion of online instruction. The majority of participants reported that there is a serious lack of online and Internet-based facilities in the Iranian EFL courses. This challenge was reported in the responses of 41 EFL teachers. Some EFL teachers asserted that some EFL students would not accept or trust online EFL instruction since they are accustomed to using traditional approaches to EFL teaching and would resist the change.
In response to the question regarding the adequacy of EFL teachers’ skills for online instruction, most EFL teachers reported that they were not competent enough for the implementation of online EFL instruction. The EFL teachers seem to lack methodological and computer knowledge to teach English online. Some teachers also stated that online EFL instruction is not suitable for all students and it can exclusively meet the needs of some specific groups of students. For example: We lack basic technological facilities in our EFL courses. How do we expect that we can run online EFL courses? (Teacher 7) I reckon students will not feel comfortable in online EFL courses. This might be because of their lack of ICT competence or their distrust in online EFL courses. I sometimes see some students who are not able to perform some basic computer operations and it's a shame. So it's not only the matter of teaching but the matter of learning as well. (Teacher 41) Online language teaching requires some specific skills on the part of EFL teachers. We don't know how to run these courses efficiently. I believe this problem discourages teachers from teaching EFL online. (Teacher 29) Not all students will benefit from online courses. We should first consider students’ needs and then plan to teach EFL online. (Teacher 33)
The survey As
Strategies to include online instruction.
|
|
Mean | SD |
|---|---|---|
|
|
||
| Computer-based and online facilities should be improved in EFL courses | 4.51 | 0.81 |
| Students and teachers should receive training on online computer literacy skills | 4.19 | 0.82 |
| Online EFL courses should be combined with face-to-face EFL courses | 4.1 | 1 |
| EFL teachers should receive training on online EFL teaching methodologies and principles | 4.01 | 1.2 |
| Online EFL courses should replace traditional EFL courses | 2.65 | 0.97 |
Likert scales: 1, strongly disagree; 2, disagree; 3, undecided; 4, agree; 5, strongly agree.
The interview The EFL teachers suggested some strategies that can be taken in order to implement online instruction. As depicted by the questionnaire results, the EFL teachers deemed that there should be adequate computer-based and Internet-based facilities to implement online EFL instruction. Receiving training for online instruction for both teachers and students was reported to be essential. In addition, 44 teachers considered implementing blended EFL instruction more beneficial than online EFL instruction: For successful implementation of online courses in EFL, we need both training and facility improvement. Of course, training should be both for EFL teachers and learners. Also, we need to have high-quality and up-to-date online facilities to implement online instruction effectively. (Teacher 11) This is my belief that the current EFL context of Iran requires the combination of online and face-to-face courses to achieve the utmost efficiency. However, I think it's too early to expect our learners and teachers to accept online courses and adapt their teaching and learning practices to it. (Teacher 27)
I know that online instruction is a large industry in language teaching nowadays, but having online courses is a good idea provided that it can be supported by face-to-face teaching sessions. (Teacher 2)
The findings indicated that the majority of language teachers who participated in this study adopted positive attitudes towards online instruction of EFL. Since teachers occupy pivotal roles in motivating students to use technology for their learning, the positive perspectives of teachers on the implementation of online instruction would facilitate the integration of online instruction in the EFL curriculum in Iran. The findings of this study are commensurate with the previous literature on teachers’ perceptions of online instruction which has revealed teachers’ acceptance of and satisfaction with online approaches to teaching (Bijeikienė, Rašinskienė, and Zutkienė 2011; Hampel and Hauck
Various factors and obstacles might discourage language teachers from implementing online instruction in the Iranian context. One significant barrier to online instruction of EFL in Iran would be a lack of online facilities and equipment. This shortcoming is not exclusively related to the quantity of online facilities but also linked to their quality. Lack of online facilities would be a demotivating factor for both students and teachers. Lack of online facilities has been an impediment to online instruction in other EFL contexts as well (Shin and Son
To overcome the problem of lack of online instruction facilities, providers of language-teaching institutions, schools and universities may fund teachers and students to have access to mobile devices. More importantly, more needs-analysis studies are required to identify the types of facilities that teachers and students need in order to implement online instruction in EFL courses. Lack of facilities and resources would act as a demotivating factor which discourages teachers and students from implementing online instruction in EFL contexts. Therefore, to provide language teachers with appropriate resources, it is essential that a number of language-teaching stakeholders, including authorities, course designers, providers, supervisors, funders and curriculum planners, implement strategies to eliminate or at least alleviate the problem of resource unavailability.
The other significant obstacle to the implementation of online instruction appears to be the limited level of computer and Internet literacy of language teachers. This finding is compatible with the results of a number of studies which have reported the issue of teachers’ low computer literacy levels as a challenge to the implementation of online instruction (e.g., Koo
The EFL teachers perceived that online instruction of EFL would not be interactive. This limitation of online instruction has been pointed out in other studies as well (Carnevale
To overcome the issue of lack of interactivity in online instruction, EFL teachers can use several types of technologies to enhance the level of interaction in online instruction. These online tools can be appropriate substitutes for traditional face-to-face communication in the classroom. For example, several research studies have revealed that the use of videoconferencing and web conferencing tools, such as Skype and GotoMeeting, can improve the interactions and computer skills of both students and teachers (Eaton,
More importantly, teachers’ perspectives on students’ lack of appropriate computer literacy needs to be considered by educational authorities and planners in Iran. This issue implies that further research is required to assess Iranian students’ computer literacy levels and identify the necessary computer and Internet skills for the effective implementation of online instruction. This finding is commensurate with the results of studies which have shown that EFL students had low levels of computer literacy in the other EFL contexts (Bataineh and Baniabdelrahman
The findings indicated that there are cultural resistances to the implementation of online instruction in Iran. The teachers believed that students might adopt negative attitudes towards online instruction. Thus, it is essential that both teachers and educational authorities in Iran take certain measures to remove cultural barriers to the implementation of online instruction. Since traditional approaches to instruction are dominant in the Iranian educational contexts, much energy and time is required to change the status quo and encourage students to adopt positive attitudes towards online instruction. The implementation of online instruction is unavoidable in the near future and educational systems and institutions which fail to accept this change might become ineffective (Ghafari and Molaei
The teachers suggested a number of strategies which might facilitate the integration of online instruction in the EFL curricula of Iran. The teachers stated that they needed to be trained for the skills required for the implementation of online instruction. Alternatively, the inclusion of skills related to online instruction in mainstream teacher education programs might be an efficient strategy to improve teachers’ levels of confidence and skills required for online instruction (Compton
Lastly, the issue of online EFL instruction is a significant one, which requires meticulous attention. More importantly, we need to assess the suitability of the implementation of online EFL instruction in various educational contexts and settings. In developing countries, the inclusion of online or blended EFL instruction would provide teachers and students with a plethora of opportunities to improve their teaching and learning practices. Implementing online EFL instruction can contribute to the transformation of traditional teaching approaches to technology-based and interactive instruction.
The conduction of this study was not without limitations. The first limitation was due to the difference between the perceptions of the three sample groups of teachers who participated in this study. The difference between their perceptions was not analysed since the number of teachers from each sample group was not equal and proportionate. As for the second limitation, since access to the Iranian EFL authorities and course designers was not possible for the researcher, they were not included in the sample. However, the inclusion of educational authorities and course designers could provide valuable insights into identifying challenges and obstacles to the implementation of online instruction in Iran.